Describe the enhancement requested
The key-tools KMS integration (org.apache.parquet.crypto.keytools) instantiates the KmsClient purely by reflection from a class name: KeyToolkit.getKmsClient(...) reads parquet.encryption.kms.client.class and calls newInstance(), requiring a public no-arg constructor, with credentials expected to arrive later via KmsClient.initialize(conf, kmsInstanceID, kmsInstanceURL, accessToken). The same reflective no-arg pattern applies to CryptoFactory / DecryptionPropertiesFactory / EncryptionPropertiesFactory via parquet.crypto.factory.class.
This works well when a KMS client is stateless and can bootstrap all of its credentials from the Configuration plus the access-token string. It does not work for clients that must be constructed with their dependencies and can't be reduced to a class name + string token, e.g.:
- clients holding a live, credential-bearing SDK handle (federated / workload-identity credentials that aren't representable as a token string);
- clients created and wired by a dependency-injection container;
- in-memory / fake KMS clients used in tests, which carry per-test state and have no meaningful no-arg form.
For these, users must build a static side-channel: register the real instance in a static map keyed by a UUID written into the Configuration, point parquet.encryption.kms.client.class at a thin reflective shim that looks the instance back up in initialize(), and override parquet.encryption.kms.instance.id per instance to avoid colliding on KeyToolkit's per-(kmsInstanceID, accessToken) client cache. That's global mutable state with its own lifecycle/leak management and a one-Configuration-per-client invariant — boilerplate every such user reinvents.
Proposal. Add an opt-in, fully backward-compatible way to supply a pre-built KmsClient (or a Supplier<KmsClient> / small factory) programmatically, which KeyToolkit.getKmsClient(...) prefers over class-name reflection when present. Reflection stays the default, so existing configs are untouched. Rough shape (names TBD):
// today (still works):
conf.set("parquet.encryption.kms.client.class", "com.example.MyKmsClient");
// proposed addition:
KeyToolkit.setKmsClientFactory(conf, () -> myPreBuiltKmsClient); // or a KmsClientFactory
initialize(...) would still be invoked on the supplied instance, so credential/token plumbing is unchanged.
Scope / non-goals. No new dependencies and no vendor-specific code — this is only about how a KmsClient is provided, not which one. PropertiesDrivenCryptoFactory, the KeyMaterial format, caching, per-column keys, and key-rotation tooling are all unchanged; this only lifts the requirement that the client be reflectively no-arg constructible.
Question for maintainers. Would a change along these lines be welcome? And do you prefer (a) a Supplier<KmsClient> set on the Configuration / read-write options, or (b) a settable KmsClientFactory on KeyToolkit? Happy to implement it and open a PR (with tests using a non-no-arg client) once there's agreement on direction.
Component(s)
Core
Describe the enhancement requested
The key-tools KMS integration (
org.apache.parquet.crypto.keytools) instantiates theKmsClientpurely by reflection from a class name:KeyToolkit.getKmsClient(...)readsparquet.encryption.kms.client.classand callsnewInstance(), requiring a public no-arg constructor, with credentials expected to arrive later viaKmsClient.initialize(conf, kmsInstanceID, kmsInstanceURL, accessToken). The same reflective no-arg pattern applies toCryptoFactory/DecryptionPropertiesFactory/EncryptionPropertiesFactoryviaparquet.crypto.factory.class.This works well when a KMS client is stateless and can bootstrap all of its credentials from the
Configurationplus the access-token string. It does not work for clients that must be constructed with their dependencies and can't be reduced to a class name + string token, e.g.:For these, users must build a static side-channel: register the real instance in a static map keyed by a UUID written into the
Configuration, pointparquet.encryption.kms.client.classat a thin reflective shim that looks the instance back up ininitialize(), and overrideparquet.encryption.kms.instance.idper instance to avoid colliding onKeyToolkit's per-(kmsInstanceID, accessToken)client cache. That's global mutable state with its own lifecycle/leak management and a one-Configuration-per-client invariant — boilerplate every such user reinvents.Proposal. Add an opt-in, fully backward-compatible way to supply a pre-built
KmsClient(or aSupplier<KmsClient>/ small factory) programmatically, whichKeyToolkit.getKmsClient(...)prefers over class-name reflection when present. Reflection stays the default, so existing configs are untouched. Rough shape (names TBD):initialize(...)would still be invoked on the supplied instance, so credential/token plumbing is unchanged.Scope / non-goals. No new dependencies and no vendor-specific code — this is only about how a
KmsClientis provided, not which one.PropertiesDrivenCryptoFactory, theKeyMaterialformat, caching, per-column keys, and key-rotation tooling are all unchanged; this only lifts the requirement that the client be reflectively no-arg constructible.Question for maintainers. Would a change along these lines be welcome? And do you prefer (a) a
Supplier<KmsClient>set on theConfiguration/ read-write options, or (b) a settableKmsClientFactoryonKeyToolkit? Happy to implement it and open a PR (with tests using a non-no-arg client) once there's agreement on direction.Component(s)
Core